Pannier Bag Recommendation......

Discussion in 'Commuting' started by Zanelad, 3 May 2019.

  1. Zanelad

    Zanelad Über Member

    Hi, can anyone recommend a single pannier bag for a newbie commuter. I usually take the car to work a couple of times a week and will use it to take shirts and underwear. I keep trousers and shirts at work for when i commute on a motorbike during the warmer months.

    I've got a rack, but would like a pannier bage for other stuff, and the shopping that Mrs Z usually wants me to pick up on the way home.

    Anyone know of a decent, inexpensive bag for my first foray into shopping by bike.

    I thank you, Z.
  2. Pat "5mph"

    Pat "5mph" A kilogrammicaly challenged woman Moderator

    Hello and welcome!
    Ime, cheap panniers are a false economy.
    Buy anything by Ortlieb if you like your stuff to stay dry.
    Shop for second hand Orlieb panniers to save money, you can get really good bargains, especially on the less popular back ones.
    lane and Heltor Chasca like this.
  3. 13 rider

    13 rider Guru

    I use a Altura Sector 20 Dryline Single Pannier for my commuting had over 3 years wear out off it and still going strong .
  4. mjr

    mjr Comfy armchair to one person & a plank to the next

    Basil sports single seems good. Bought two for someone (I prefer saddlebags and/or double panniers) more than three years ago, and two sometimes get used in preference to double panniers. I think there's now a more designy version too.
  5. I like Ortleibs. I have 2 sets, fully waterproof and will last for years. But overpriced.

    I am sure Decathlon or Halfords must supply decent panniers at cheaper prices.
  6. Heltor Chasca

    Heltor Chasca Out-Riding the Black Dog

    Ortlieb. Mine are 15 years old and totally waterproof. I have used them to float down the Zambezi before. Twice.
  7. MichaelW2

    MichaelW2 Veteran

    Features to look for include
    a good quick release mount that will still remain hooked on when broken.
    Lightweight stiffener in back.
    Tough material that does not flap around.
    Rear pocket is useful but i use one without.
  8. stoatsngroats

    stoatsngroats Guru

    South East
    I have only tried Ortlieb, and have no issues with them touring a little, and then weekend use. They have been great. I think they are a little overpriced, but I think you get what you pay for.

    I wouldn’t think twice about using these in any weather, or for any touring I would be doing.
  9. vickster

    vickster Legendary Member

    Budget? Define inexpensive

    I swear by the Topeak trunk bags with fold down panniers but you do need a compatible rack as it slides on

    I’ve finally bitten the bullet on a pair of Ortlieb bikepacker plus but they did cost around £125 as I wanted good quality. There are cheaper from the brand but I didn’t want the ones that are like big sacks. These have outside pockets for accessing valuables.

    That said @Reynard recently got a £20 jobbie from Decathlon
    Reynard likes this.
  10. Reynard

    Reynard Guru

    Cambridgeshire, UK
    The £20 Decathlon one I got isn't bad - it is what it is. It'll do nicely for what I need it to do (keep gubbins in for days out / longer rides / occasional shopping trip), but I'm not certain it would stand up terribly well to seriously hard use i.e. commuting. Nor would it stand up to a deluge. I couldn't justify spending more, plus I'm limited by the fact that I ride a junior bike, and a lot of luggage is simply too big or the wrong shape or both...

    Decathlon does have a slightly more spendy one (£35) which looks like a much better bet for commuting.

    And as @vickster says, might be worth considering a rack bag instead of a pannier. I've bought a Ridge rack bag from Halfords because it fits on my bike. Seems pretty well made and will take maps, a jacket and a packed lunch with room to spare. The topeak bags are really nice, but are too big for my bike, so can't comment on those.
  11. CXRAndy

    CXRAndy Guru

    I have those too. Very convenient, I really like them 20190214_124112.jpg
  12. OP

    Zanelad Über Member

    Thanks to all who replied. I popped into Decathlon yesterday and picked up one of their messenger bags that clips to a rack. It's smaller than a conventional pannier, but I wont be taking that much stuff to the office. Packed lunch and a couple of tubes, pump and lock etc and still have room for the milk or whatever I'm told to bring home.

    It looks sturdy with decent fittings. We'll see how we get on.
    Reynard and mcshroom like this.
  13. MontyVeda

    MontyVeda a short-tempered ill-controlled small-minded troll

    Mine seemed expensive at the time of purchase... but I know they'll outlive my memory of the cost, and probably me.
    steveindenmark likes this.
  14. I bought some Biltema panniers in Denmark. Its a bit like Halfords. After 3 years of daily use, they are in excellent condition. About a quarter of the ortleib price.
  15. straas

    straas Über Member

    Whatever you get, make sure they're properly waterproof - they can be a bit useless otherwise.

    I have carradice, similar material to the ortlieb, so never had an issue with damp.

    Downsides to the carradice:

    - They don't stand up very well when they're off the bike
    - They're awkward to carry off the bike, some sort of a shoulder strap would help.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice